Suite de la zone commentaires sur le film de Martin Durkin The Great Global Warming Swindle (la grande escroquerie du réchauffement climatique).
Suite de la zone commentaires sur le film de Martin Durkin The Great Global Warming Swindle (la grande escroquerie du réchauffement climatique).
231 réponses à “La grande escroquerie du réchauffement climatique”
Partial Response to the London Channel 4 Film "The Great Global Warming Swindle"
Carl Wunsch 11 March 2007
http://ocean.mit.edu/~cwunsch/…..l4response
Carl Wunsch: "I should never have trusted Channel 4"
http://comment.independent.co……359057.ece
Carl Wunsch, professor of physical oceanography at the Massachusetts
Institute of Technology, said the film, The Great Global Warming
Swindle, was "grossly distorted" and "as close to pure propaganda as anything since World War Two".
http://environment.guardian.co…..ge/story/0,,2031457,00.html
Pas malin ce Carl Wunsch; mais que ne ferait-on pas pour apparaître sur le devant de la scène du grand spectacle du siècle?
Et puis cette allusion à world war two me rappelle le schwindle des armes de destruction massive bien plus proche de nous que la seconde guerre mondiale
Laisse tomber, Raoul, Tu parles à des autistes lobotomisés par le libéralisme. Tu va t’épuiser.
Salut Peak,
Je pense que c’est important que chacun ait le droit de s’exprimer, de dire ce qu’il pense.
Il y a des gens qui se sentent manipulés par les médias, par nos dirigeants, par les scientifiques, a tel point qu’ils en viennent à nier que la terre s’échauffe. C’est intéressant de s’interroger pourquoi. Pourquoi une telle radicalisation ?
Au fait, merci à Frédéric d’avoir remis en ligne mon message : j’avais cru au départ que tu voulais me censurer quand je citais Carl Wunsch !
Personne n’a nié que la terre s’échauffe ! Pas la peine de caricaturer la position de vos interlocuteurs pour les critiquer, c’est de la rhétorique, pas de la discussion.
Dans les premières minutes du film, on vous explique quelle est la position des sceptiques. Alors regardez ce qui y est dit au lieu d’avancer des énormités. 😡
#2, j’ai beau regardé les réponses de Carl Wunsch, je n’ai trouvé nulle part où il dit « as close to pure propaganda as anything since World War Two ». Sans doute une tentative de désinformation typique des journaux anglais, relayé par Raoul.
De toute façon, je comprends que Wunsch soit bien grillé et qu’il proteste. Quand on annonce devant des millions de gens que « les modélisateurs ont tendance à produire des résultats spectaculaires au lieu des résultats exacts » et qu’on est soi-même modélisateur, ça craint pour sa propre crédibilité. Le voilà pris dans son propre piège en flagrant délit de distorsion de la réalité.
Les paroles s’en vont, les écrits restent et les images qui voyagent par internet, c’est encore pire.
Salut miniTAX,
Tu fais à l’évidence partie des gens qui savent que le réchauffement est provoqué par l’homme : mais ce n’est pas le cas de tous le monde (une minorité continue de le nier).
C’est intéressant de s’interroger sur les raisons du blocage.
Quel est ton avis là dessus ?
Ouh, les injures, c’est hors charte ça ! Toi en tout cas, tu ne t’es pas beaucoup épuisé en arguments sérieux
MiniTAX : « j’ai beau regardé les réponses de Carl Wunsch, je n’ai trouvé nulle part où il dit “as close to pure propaganda as anything since World War Two”. «
Un petit coup de pouce :
http://www.google.fr/search?hl…..War+Two%22
Salut Raoul,
Non tu te trompes, tu ne connais pas les raisons du scepticisme. Pourtant c’est bien expliqué dans le film. Quant à dire qu’une minorité continue de nier le réchauffement, c’est une affirmation sans fondement. Peux-tu me citer le nom d’un scientifique sceptique qui nie le réchauffement stp ?
#10,
Montre nous la lettre, l’email, l’enregistrement… de Wunsch où il dit “as close to pure propaganda as anything since World War Two” et non des ouis dire de the Guardian ou l’hystérique Monbiot.
Si tu ne peux pas, reconnais ton erreur et arrête de colporter des âneries. Si tu peux, je n’ai aucun problème à faire amende honorable.
Et tu ne m’as toujours pas répondu, est ce que Carl Wunsch a porté plainte contre le réalisateur du film? Sinon, pourquoi laisser entendre cela comme si c’était une certitude. Pourquoi dans ton lien en #1, tu n’as extrait que ce qui t’arrange et non la réponse de Durkin 2 lignes plus bas? Ce n’est pas honnête comme procédé ça !
Sur le site du MIT :
Carl Wunsch : What we now have is an out-and-out propaganda piece, in which there is not even a gesture toward balance or explanation of why
many of the extended inferences drawn in the film are not widely
accepted by the scientific community…
A director not intending to produce pure propaganda would have tried to eliminate that piece of disinformation.
http://ocean.mit.edu/~cwunsch/…..l4response
Lettre de Carl Wunsch à Steven Green (Head of Production
Wag TV 2D Leroy House 436 Essex Road London N1 3QP)
http://ocean.mit.edu/~cwunsch/…..l4response
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%
Mr. Steven Green
Head of Production
Wag TV
2D Leroy House
436 Essex Road
London N1 3QP
10 March 2007
Dear Mr. Green:
I am writing to record what I told you on the telephone yesterday about your Channel 4 film « The Global Warming Swindle. » Fundamentally, I am the one who was swindled—please read the email below that was sent to me (and re-sent by you). Based upon this email and subsequent telephone conversations, and discussions with the Director, Martin Durkin, I thought I was being asked to appear in a film that would discuss in a balanced way the complicated elements of understanding of climate change—in the best traditions of British television. Is there any indication in the email evident to an outsider that the product would be so tendentious, so unbalanced?
I was approached, as explained to me on the telephone, because
I was known to have been unhappy with some of the more excitable climate-change stories in the British media, most conspicuously the notion that the Gulf Stream could disappear, among others. When a journalist approaches me suggesting a « critical approach » to a technical subject, as the email states, my inference is that we are to discuss which elements are contentious, why they are contentious,
and what the arguments are on all sides. To a scientist, « critical » does not mean a hatchet job—it means a thorough-going examination of the science. The scientific subjects described in the email, and in the previous and subsequent telephone conversations, are complicated, worthy of exploration, debate, and an educational effort with the public. Hence my willingness to participate. Had the words « polemic », or « swindle » appeared in these preliminary discussions, I would have
instantly declined to be involved.
I spent hours in the interview describing many of the problems of understanding the ocean in climate change, and the ways in which some of the more dramatic elements get
exaggerated in the media relative to more realistic, potentially
truly catastrophic issues, such as the implications of the oncoming sea level rise. As I made clear, both in the
preliminary discussions, and in the interview itself, I believe that
global warming is a very serious threat that needs equally serious
discussion and no one seeing this film could possibly deduce that.
What we now have is an out-and-out propaganda piece, in which
there is not even a gesture toward balance or explanation of why
many of the extended inferences drawn in the film are not widely
accepted by the scientific community. There are so many examples, it’s hard to know where to begin, so I will cite only one: a speaker asserts, as is true, that carbon dioxide is only
a small fraction of the atmospheric mass. The viewer is left to
infer that means it couldn’t really matter. But even a beginning
meteorology student could tell you that the relative masses of gases
are irrelevant to their effects on radiative balance. A director
not intending to produce pure propaganda would have tried to eliminate that piece of disinformation.
An example where my own discussion was grossly distorted by context:
I am shown explaining that a warming ocean could expel more
carbon dioxide than it absorbs — thus exacerbating the greenhouse
gas buildup in the atmosphere and hence worrisome. It
was used in the film, through its context, to imply
that CO2 is all natural, coming from the ocean, and that
therefore the human element is irrelevant. This use of my remarks, which
are literally what I said, comes close to fraud.
I have some experience in dealing with TV and print reporters
and do understand something of the ways in which one can be
misquoted, quoted out of context, or otherwise misinterpreted. Some
of that is inevitable in the press of time or space or in discussions of
complicated issues. Never before, however, have I had
an experience like this one. My appearance in the « Global Warming
Swindle » is deeply embarrasing, and my professional reputation
has been damaged. I was duped—an uncomfortable position in which to be.
At a minimum, I ask that the film should never be seen again publicly
with my participation included. Channel 4 surely owes an apology to
its viewers, and perhaps WAGTV owes something to Channel 4. I will be
taking advice as to whether I should proceed to make some more formal protest.
Sincerely,
Carl Wunsch
Cecil and Ida Green Professor of
Physical Oceanography
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
cc: Hamish Mykura, Channel 4
(Hard copy to follow)
%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%5
From: jo locke=20
Sent: 19 September 2006 16:22
To: Carl Wunsch
Cc: Eliya Arman
Subject: Climate Change Documentary
=20
Dear Professor Wunsch,
=20
Many thanks for taking the time to talk to me this morning. I found it
really useful and now have the issues much clearer in my mind.
=20
I wanted to email you to outline the approach we will be taking with our
film to clarify our position. We are making a feature length documentary
about global warming for Channel Four in the UK. The aim of the film is
to examine critically the notion that recent global warming is primarily
caused by industrial emissions of CO2. It explores the scientific
evidence which jars with this hypothesis and explores alternative
theories such as solar induced climate change. Given the seemingly
inconclusive nature of the evidence, it examines the background to the
apparent consensus on this issue, and highlights the dangers involved,
especially to developing nations, of policies aimed at limiting
industrial growth.
=20
We would like to do an interview with you to discuss the notion that
there is a scientific consensus on the effects of global warming on the
Great Ocean Conveyor Belt, the Gulf Stream and the North Atlantic Drift.
It has been widely reported that Britain and Western Europe could soon
be plunged into a mini ice age, and we would like to show that it is
simply not true that they will shut down. We would like to talk to you
about the numerical models and whether they give us a realistic
perspective of the impact of climate change on the oceans. We would also
like to talk to you about the ‘memory’ of oceans, and how it can take
varying amounts of time for a disturbance to be readable in the North
Atlantic. Fundamentally, we would like to ask you whether scientists
have enough information about the complex nature of our climate system.
Do the records go back far enough to identify climate trends, and can we
conclusively separate human induced change from natural change?
=20
Our filming schedule is still relatively fluid at the moment, but we
hope to be in Boston around the second week of November. Please don’t
hesitate to contact me or my producer, Eliya Arman, if you have any
further questions, and I look forward to hearing from you soon.
=20
Yours sincerely,
=20
Jo Locke
=20
Jo Locke
Assistant Producer
WagTV
2d Leroy House
436 Essex Road
London N1 3QP
t 020 7688 5191 f 020 7688 1702
http://www.wagtv.com =20
Il Semble que tes premieres affirmations ne correspondent toujours pas, enfin bon. (Un terme comme WW2, c’est comme negationiste, c’est fort.)
Perso, voila ce que j’en pense des modeles climatiques.
Et pour le moment, les seules consequences visible du RC, ce sont les insultes et l’ ad hominem envers les sceptiques. Remarquez tout y passe, quel generosite. Sympa.
#13, #14
Oui donc bref, mettre “as close to pure propaganda as anything since World War Two” dans la bouche de Carl Wunsch, avec une claire référence au nazisme et au négationisme, c’est dégueulasse.
Raoul, tu nous copieras 100x « je ne collerai plus de liens douteux » 😉
D’ailleurs, et c’est un scoop, les sceptiques ont découvert pourquoi Carl Wunsch a retourné sa veste avec de sa protestation indignée. Regarde ce qu’on lui a fait :

3. Peak | 3/04/2007 @ 20:53
Laisse tomber, Raoul, Tu parles à des autistes lobotomisés par le libéralisme. Tu va t’épuiser.
Si tu penses débarrasser le monde de la société de consommation et de la course à la croissance en agitant l’épouventail du réchauffement climatique , je pense que c’est toi qui va t’épuiser
MiniTAX,
Tu donnes une interprétation personnelle (BD rigolote) de la demande de rectification qu’a effectué Wunsch, sans aucun autre argument qu’une intime conviction. Cependant The Guardian n’est pas un journal « douteux ». Je te renvoie donc le « tu nous copiera 100 fois ».
Ce qui est clair, c’est que Wunsh s’est senti trompé et qu’il qualifie bien le film de « propagande », de « désinformation ».
La référence a le seconde guerre mondiale : l’hypothèse la plus propable est qu’un journaliste du Guardian l’a interviewé et qu’il s’est exprimé ainsi dans un moment où le sentiment d’injustice l’a submergé (je pense que c’est exagéré de faire cette comparaison même si, effectivement, les films de propagande que l’on diffusait durant la seconde guerre mondiale étaient de bien meilleure qualité). Mais on ne peut pas exclure que le Guardian a rajouté artificiellement cette référence à la seconde guerre mondiale, et si c’est le cas, ce n’est pas correct. Il te reste à trouver des preuves permettant de nous montrer qu’il y a eu effectivement déformation des propos de Wunsch dans The Guardian. Bon courage.
Nicolas Et pour le moment, les seules consequences visible du RC, ce sont les insultes et l’ ad hominem envers les sceptiques.
Salut Nicolas,
Tu peux me dire qui j’ai insulté sur ce blog ?
Carl Wunsch place en référence l’article du Guardian sur sa page personnelle :
http://puddle.mit.edu/~cwunsch/
Le débat est clos.
Oups, c’est un autre article du Guardian sur le même sujet.
Le débat reste ouvert.
L’analyse du film par les scientifique du British Antartic Survey :
http://www.antarctica.ac.uk/Ne……php?id=50
Par les scientifiques de RealClimate :
http://www.realclimate.org/ind…../swindled/
Par l’Académie des sciences de Grande Bretagne :
The Royal Society’s response to the documentary « The Great Global Warming Swindle »
http://www.royalsoc.ac.uk/news.asp?id=6089
British Antarctic Survey : Channel 4 used seriously flawed data on which to base their programme.
Royal Society : Those who promote fringe scientific views but ignore the weight of evidence are playing a dangerous game
RealClimate : We were hoping for important revelations and final proof that we have all been hornswoggled by the climate Illuminati, but it just repeated the usual specious claims we hear all the time. We feel swindled.
Une anayse du film par The Secretary of State of Environment, David Milliband (Ministre de l’Environnement), sur son blog :
http://www.davidmiliband.defra…../5960.aspx
Pour avoir une idée de la façon dont répond Martin Durkin (le réalisateur du film d’escroquerie) aux personnes qui lui envoient de riches commentaires sur son film (propos en ligne sur le site du MIT : http://ocean.mit.edu/~cwunsch/…..emails.htm )
Martin Durkin s’adressant à Armand Leroi : You’re a big daft cock
Martin Durkin s’adressant à Simon Singh : Go and fuck yourself
C’est assez révèlateur sur son état d’esprit, n’est-ce pas ?
Dans The Time :
In an e-mail exchange leaked to The Times, Martin Durkin, the executive producer of The Great Global Warming Swindle, responded to the concerns of Dr Armand Leroi, from Imperial College, and Simon Singh, the respected scientific author, by telling them to “go and f*** yourself”.
The tirade has caused Dr Leroi to withdraw his cooperation from another Channel 4 project with Mr Durkin on race, The Times has learnt.
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/t…..517515.ece
#19
Bonjour Raoul,
Je suis certain que si vous nous faisiez l’honneur de dire ce que vous trouvez « pas bien » (scientifiquement bien-entendu) dans le film que vous semblez ne pas apprécier, ça élèverait énormément le niveau du débat (sans vouloir vexer personne).
Salut Frédéric,
J’ai déjà largement répondu : se baser sur des données fausses pour faire un reportage destiné au grand public, c’est pas top. Tu n’es pas d’accord ?
Quand on connait le background de Martin Durkin et quand on lit la réaction de Carl Wunsch, on se dit que la référence à l’escroquerie est bien choisie dans le titre.
Original Message—– From: Armand Leroi [mailto:a.leroi@imperial.ac.uk] Sent: 09 March 2007 02:38 To: Martin Durkin; lbolch@channel4.co.uk Cc: simonsingh@msn.com; ben@badscience.net Subject: The Global Warming Swindle
Dear Martin,
I thought that your programme made some good points (the politics of the IPCC) and some bad points (anthropogenic global warming is a conspiracy to keep Africa underdeveloped). But what fascinated me were your scientific claims, in particular, your display of Friis-Christensen’s time-series correlations between solar activity and terrestrial temperatures since 1860. The correlation was, indeed, amazing — the two variables track each other perfectly! Maybe you’re right: maybe it’s all just the sun.
So, I looked up the paper. It was published in 1991 — in SCIENCE — and you can’t get better than that. ( SCIENCE 254: 698-700). So looked to see who had cited it — and promptly came across a series of papers by Peter Laut who argues that Friis-Christensen’s data are wrong. And by that I mean bogus.
Now, I am no climate scientist — but I can read these graphs; there’s nothing complicated about them. And what Laut has to say is shocking and convincing (see attached summary article but there’s also a much longer, and much more damning, technical article). He says that Friis-Christensen repeatedly engaged in « unacceptable handling of observational data ». To put this bluntly: the data that you showed in your programme were wrong — and may have been deliberately faked, for they were wrong in several different ways. And if you correct the data, the correlation in recent years goes away.
Fascinatingly, Laut points out that Friis-Christensen’s data, far from having been suppressed, have received widespread media coverage (and they’ve been cited over 300 times in the scientific literature). Indeed, in 2001, Friis-Christensen and colleagues were the subject of a Danish TV doc in « The Climate Conflict », which presented them as an « ingenious mavericks who…now fight a scientific establishment represented by the IPCC. » Gosh. Sounds familiar.
There is much more that could be said about your programme — such as the gross caricature that it gave of a scientific community which, contra your film, continually debates the various causes of global warming — but, as I said, I am not a climate scientist. But it does show — what abundant experience has already taught me — that, left to their own devices, TV producers simply cannot be trusted to tell the truth. I am very disappointed.
I am copying this to Lou Bolch. And to Simon Singh, Ben Goldacre, and Olivia Judson — fellow connoisseurs of this sort of thing.
Best
Armand
Voilà une très bonne critique de ce film :
The Great Climate Change Swindle?
Several people have said to me that they couldn’t quite believe what they were being told in Channel 4’s programme last week on climate change – and I promised yesterday in my interview on the Today programme to put the facts on my blog. Below I have set out what Defra scientists say about the 11 main allegations in the programme. You can read for yourself what the International Panel on Climate Change say or the statement of the Academies of Science of the 11 largest countries in the world.
I am convinced well beyond reasonable doubt that the swindle is not being perpetrated by the vast, vast majority of scientists in the world. There will always be people with conspiracy theories trying to do down the scientific consensus, and that is part of scientific and democratic debate, but the science of climate change looks like fact to me. If the effect of the programme, instead of making people think, is in fact to make them disregard the accepted science (in other words stop thinking) then that would be a real swindle.
The following key allegations are paraphrased from the programme “The Great Global Warming Swindle”.
1. The high temperatures seen in the last few decades are not unique. Temperatures are naturally variable and have been higher in the past, for example, during the Medieval Warm period (800-1300AD).
It is true that temperatures have been higher than today’s in the distant past. However, for the Northern Hemisphere at least, it is clear the rapid warming of the past half century has resulted in a level of warmth not seen in at least 500 years, and likely for at least the past 1300 years. For the Southern Hemisphere, long records of temperatures are more scarce and therefore it is difficult to draw such clear conclusions. The important characteristic about the current warmth is that it is global, whereas many previous warming periods have occurred over smaller areas.
Globally, eleven out of the last twelve years (1995-2006) rank among the warmest 12 years since records began in 1850. Over the past century, temperatures have risen by 0.74°C, with 0.4°C of this warming since 1970.
Climate models indicate that if greenhouse gas emissions continue unabated, by the middle of the century the world could reach a level of warmth not seen since the peak of the last interglacial period, around 125,000 years ago. At that time, sea levels were around 4 – 6m greater than today.
2. The key piece of evidence used by scientists to prove the warming effect of greenhouse gases is that in the past, on timescales of hundreds of millennia, global temperatures have followed carbon dioxide concentrations, i.e. when temperatures are high, carbon dioxide levels are high. But this is not true, changes in carbon dioxide concentrations actually lag behind changes in temperature.
Firstly, this is not the key piece of evidence for human-induced climate change. Basic physics tells us that an increase in greenhouse gas concentrations will have a warming effect on the climate. Levels of carbon dioxide alone now far exceed that at any time in at least the past 650,000 years. The trend and pattern of current warming is consistent with what we would expect for the observed rise in greenhouse gases.
Secondly, it is true that temperature changes appear to have preceded CO2 changes through glacial-interglacial cycles in the distant past. However, this just suggests that CO2 was not the initial driver of the glacial cycles. The evidence suggests that CO2 levels rose as a result of warming, possibly as the surface of the ocean warmed. As CO2 has a warming effect on the climate, it would then act as a feedback – stimulating additional warming.
Now human emissions are causing the rise in CO2 levels, and therefore, the resulting warming of the climate.
Aside: Climate models predict that the positive feedback effect between temperature and CO2 seen in the distant past could happen again in the future if global temperatures reach high enough levels.
3. The trend in carbon dioxide concentrations over the past century does not match that of temperature, and therefore, carbon dioxide can not be the key driver. For example, in the middle of the century, when emissions were growing rapidly, temperatures actually fell.
It is true that the trend in CO2 concentrations over the last century does not exactly match the trend in temperature. But we do not expect it to. This is for two key reasons. Firstly, there is a time lag between warming and changes in CO2, caused by the inertia in the climate system. Secondly, greenhouse gases are not the only determinant of temperature. Aerosols, which are also emitted from human activities, are also important and can be shown to explain much of the cooling seen in the middle of the 20th century.
Climate models represent the lag in the response of the climate, and the influence of many external factors. These show that the trend in temperatures does match what we would expect. Based on these analyses and others, the recent report of the IPCC concluded that most of the warming over at least the last 50 years has been caused by the rise in greenhouse gas concentrations.
4. Most of the 20th century warming occurred before 1940, when carbon dioxide emissions were still relatively low.
This first statement is not correct. Global temperatures did rise during the first few decades of this century, but much of the warming seen this century has occurred since around 1970 (0.4°C of the total 0.74°C warming). Global temperatures have risen almost continuously since 1950. The linear growth rate in temperature during the past 50 years is nearly twice that of the last 100 years. While the IPCC concluded that much of the warming over the past 50 years is very likely due to greenhouse gases, the cause of the warming in the first half of the century is not clear. Current thinking is that it was likely a mixture of natural and human factors.
5. The patterns of warming in the atmosphere do not match what we would expect for a warming caused by rising greenhouse gas concentrations and therefore, can not be the cause.
This is not correct. The patterns of warming in the atmosphere do match what we would expect. Previously reported discrepancies were due to problems with early versions of observed data from satellites and radiosondes. These errors were corrected a few years ago.
6. Human emissions are only a tiny fraction of total natural emissions and therefore can not be important in causing climate change.
It is true that human emissions are relatively small compared to natural emissions, particularly from ecosystems and the oceans. However, these natural emissions are in balance: the amount emitted is then reabsorbed. Human emissions tip the balance and lead to an accumulation of gases in the atmosphere. The human source can be shown through, for example, examining the chemical make-up and distribution of CO2 in the atmosphere.
7. There is no evidence that human emissions are causing the current warming trend.
This is not true. As stated in the recent IPCC report, a growing body of evidence demonstrates that increases in greenhouse gas concentrations, due to human emissions, have caused most of the warming observed over the past half century. Both the spatial patterns and trend of warming can only be explained by the inclusion of human emissions. It is very unlikely that the rapid increase in global temperatures seen over the past half century could be caused by natural factors alone. For example, the most recent report of the IPCC concludes that the warming effect of human emissions is around ten times that of solar variations.
8. Attribution studies rely on climate models, but these models are tuned to give the right results and therefore can not be trusted.
Climate models are an essential tool in understanding how the climate will respond to changes in greenhouse gas concentrations, and other external effects, such as solar output changes and volcanoes. The models use fundamental physics and chemistry to simulate processes within the climate system and are rigorously assessed to ensure their reliability.
9. Past changes in climate have been driven by natural factors, such as changes in solar radiation and cosmic rays. It is most likely that these same natural factors are causing the current warming.
It is true that natural factors have driven climate changes in the past. But it is considered very unlikely that the rapid increase in global temperatures seen over the past half century could be caused by natural factors alone. Both the spatial patterns and trend of warming can only be explained by the inclusion of human emissions.
It is clear that changes in solar radiation are a significant driver of the climate. However, there is strong evidence that changes in solar radiation could not have caused the rapid warming observed over the past half century. The warming effects of changes in solar output since pre-industrial are estimated to be less than around one tenth that of human emissions of greenhouse gases.
Despite recent claims, there is no scientifically robust evidence suggesting that cosmic ray variations have, or could even, play a significant role in recent warming. Variations in cosmic rays over the past few decades can not explain the long-term global warming trend.
10. Observed changes in sea ice are due to natural factors.
Sea ice extent does change naturally, but the current reduction in sea ice extent is in line with what we would expect in a warming world.
11. The scientific process is biased.
The IPCC is the most authoritative voice on climate change. Its assessments represent the consensus of thousands of scientists worldwide, based on peer-reviewed research. Objectivity is ensured by the broad and open review process and shared responsibility for the report. No one government, organisation or individual has sole responsibility for any part of the report.
posted on 14 March 2007 13:09 by David Miliband
http://www.davidmiliband.defra…../5960.aspx
Frédéric : Bonjour Raoul,
Je suis certain que si vous nous faisiez l’honneur de dire ce que vous trouvez “pas bien” (scientifiquement bien-entendu) dans le film que vous semblez ne pas apprécier, ça élèverait énormément le niveau du débat (sans vouloir vexer personne).
Suite à la diffusion de ce programme, de très bonnes critiques ont été réalisées par des scientifiques, des journalistes ou des politiques. Et on les remercie : cela élève le débat.
Solar activity and terrestrial climate: an analysis of some
purported correlations
Journal of Atmospheric and Solar-Terrestrial Physics 65 (2003) 801– 812
Peter Laut
Department of Physics, Technical University of Denmark, DK-2800 Lyngby, Denmark
http://stephenschneider.stanfo…..ut2003.pdf
Abstract
The last decade has seen a revival of various hypotheses claiming a strong correlation between solar activity and a number
of terrestrial climate parameters: Links between cosmic rays and cloud cover, 1rst total cloud cover and then only low clouds,
and between solar cycle lengths and Northern Hemisphere land temperatures. These hypotheses play an important role in the
scienti1c as well as in the public debate about the possibility or reality of a man-made global climate change. I have analyzed
a number of published graphs which have played a major role in these debates and which have been claimed to support
solar hypotheses. My analyses show that the apparent strong correlations displayed on these graphs have been obtained by
an incorrect handling of the physical data. Since the graphs are still widely referred to in the literature and their misleading
character has not yet been generally recognized, I have found it appropriate to deliver the present overview. Especially, I want
to caution against drawing any conclusions based upon these graphs concerning the possible wisdom or futility of reducing
the emissions of man-made greenhouse gases.
My 1ndings do not by any means rule out the existence of important links between solar activity and terrestrial climate. Such
links have over the years been demonstrated by many authors. The sole objective of the present analysis is to draw attention
to the fact that some of the widely publicized, apparent correlations do not properly reflect the underlying physical data.
C’est étrange, Martin Durkin ne mentionne pas cette étude dans son film.
Nicolas : Perso, voila ce que j’en pense des modeles climatiques. http://republiquefromagere.blogspot.com/index.html
Salut Nicolas,
Merci pour le lien vers ton blog.
Un petit problème : tu confonds météo et climat.
Je te conseille cet article de vulgarisation pour que tu aies un aperçu de ce qu’est la physique de la modélisation du climat :
http://www.giss.nasa.gov/resea…..ncais.html
La propriété la plus intéressante du système climatique est l’émergence. C’est-à-dire que les phénomènes de grande échelle ne sont pas simplement des fonctions triviales de la physique de petite échelle mais qu’ils résultent de la complexité du système. Par exemple, aucune formule ne décrit la zone de convergences intertropicales qui résulte d’une combinaison du cycle saisonnier du rayonnement solaire, des propriétés de la convection humide, de la rotation de la Terre, et ainsi de suite. Ces qualités émergentes font que la modélisation climatique est fondamentalement différente de la résolution numérique d’équations délicates.
La modélisation du climat est aussi fondamentalement différente de la prévision du temps. Le temps météorologique est un problème de valeur initiale: étant donné la situation d’aujourd’hui quelle sera la situation de demain? Le temps météorologique est chaotique; des différences imperceptibles dans l’état initial de l’atmosphère conduisent à des conditions radicalement différentes une semaine ou deux plus tard. Par contre, le climat est un problème de conditions aux limites — une description statistique de l’état moyen et de la variabilité d’un système, et non pas un chemin individuel à travers l’espace des phases.
http://www.giss.nasa.gov/resea…..ncais.html
# A Raoul…
C’est rigolo, mais après avoir lu ton blog et ton CV je me suis rendu compte que bien qu’étant un peu plus vieux que toi :
– mon CV ressemble un peu au tien (Mécaflotte, Ingé, Poly-Montréal 1992…) et du coup,
– mon point de vue sur la dynamique du problème est globalement identique.
A mon sens la climatologie souffre entre autres d’une absence de modèle global de circulation (contrairement à la météo avec Navier-Stokes et cie…). Ce qui n’ôte rien au côté instable du système dynamique qui peut la représenter.
Dés lors, toutes ces petites considérations sur les cernes des arbres, les pollens fossiles, les bulles de gaz dans la glace… Sont dérisoires et probablement TOUTES fausses et non pertinentes non seulement en terme de REPRESENTATIVITE du système mais aussi et surtout en terme de PREVISIONS.
Dans un autre post, j’avais fait remarquer qu’un des opposants (brillant chercheur) au réchauffement était un dynamicien de formation (travail sur le chaos).
Je maintiens qu’à terme la réponse définitive sur cette histoire de climat viendra de là : on MONTRERA que l’évolution du climat terrestre est quasiment imprévisible même dans les grandes lignes.
Cordialement.
PS : j’ai lu sur certains posts que même des scientifiques opposants au réchauffement d’origine anthropique/CO2 ne nient pas que la terre se réchauffe.
Est-ce le cas de tous ?
Je ne suis personnellement pas convaincu qu’on puisse seulement DIRE que la terre se réchauffe (ou se refroidisse…)j je pense que cela n’a pas de sens de définir une température moyenne de notre planète.
D’ailleurs les données satellitaires ne confirment-elles pas qu’on ne note AUCUN réchauffement ?
C’est rigolo, mais après avoir lu ton blog et ton CV je me suis rendu compte que bien qu’étant un peu plus vieux que toi :
– mon CV ressemble un peu au tien (Mécaflotte, Ingé, Poly-Montréal 1992…) et du coup,
– mon point de vue sur la dynamique du problème est globalement identique.
Salut Murps,
D’où l’intérêt de sortir du conditionnement lié à son parcours personnel.
[…modéré]Le torchon du Guardian n'est pas une interview de Wunsch mais des mensonges éhontés du journaliste qui se permet de mettre entre guillemets ses affabulations au sujet de WW2 pour les faire passer pour des paroles de Wunsch.
[…modéré]
Quelques données intéressantes à propos de Channel 4 sur le forum « eco-citoyen.org :
http://www.eco-citoyen.org/For…..95-20.html
Alain : Channel 4 est une chaîne de télévision britannique du service public.
Elle a été créée par une loi du parlement et a commencé à diffuser ses programmes le 2 novembre 1982. À la différence de la chaine de service public BBC, Channel 4 ne reçoit aucun fond public. Tout ses programmes sont financés par ses activités commerciales, dont les publicités.
http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Channel_4
En 1997, Channel 4 diffuse une série intitulée « Against Nature » ou les environnementalistes sont comparés à des Nazis conspirant contre les pauvres de ce Monde. Encore une fois, une série ne présentant qu’un seul point de vue.
Saisie par le cas, la commission indépendante de Télévision constata que les personalités utilisées pour la réalisation de cette série furent exploitées et leurs propos tirés hors du contexte initial.
Channel 4 fut obligée de présenter en direct des excuses.
http://www.monbiot.com/archive…..ied-truth/
http://www.ourcivilisation.com…..inatur.htm
En Octobre 2003 Channel 4 pousse la téléréalité à son comble avec une roulette Russe en direct
http://www.toutelatele.com/art…..ticle=2797
Novembre 2004, sous prétexte de se substituer à la Science, idée d’un programme tout ce qu’il y a de plus macabre, filmer la décomposition d’un corps Humain
http://www.casafree.com/module…..toryid=197
En Mars 2006, reportage tronqué de channel 4 sur le Vénézuela
Channel 4 prépare les esprits à une invasion du Venezuela John Pilger
http://www.oulala.net/Portail/…..ticle=2351
2007 Elle n’hésite pas à publier des séquences qualifiées unanimement de « Raciste » au cours de l’émission « Big Brother Celebrity »
http://www.liberation.fr/actua…..505.FR.php
Il semble dès lors évident que Channel 4 est plutôt coutumière de la sensation et en règle général recherche tout ce qui peut booster son audience.
Peu importe la teneur du programme, être à contre courant et choquer semble faire partie de la ligne de conduite de cette chaîne qui en outre, peu importe la morale, du moment que cela raporte!
Quelques données sur Channel 4 et le film en question sur eco-citoyen.org :
http://www.eco-citoyen.org/For…..95-20.html
#34, les données satellites montrent un réchauffement bien plus faible que les températures au sol, malgré la récente correction suite à une erreur d’algorithme. D’ailleurs, les alarmistes ont profité de cet événement pour critiquer les données satellite qui foutent en l’air leur théorie sur l’influence des GES, en oubliant de préciser que même avec la correction, la hausse constatée par les satellites est bien plus faible que la hausse de la température de surface.
Et malgré le fait que la température de surface est mesurée par des stations dont la couverture terrestre et océanique est ridicule (environ 2.000 stations pour le réseau GISS… pour toute la Terre !), le GIEC continue de l’utiliser. S’il utilise la température indiquée par les satellites, le monde se rendra compte que toute cette industrie du réchauffement n’est rien de plus qu’une hystérie collective couverte par une mascarade de science.
A raoul
Ce je suis tout a fait conscient de la difference entre meteo et climat.
IL n’empeche que parler de climat global ca n’a pas vraiment de sens.
Et il me semble que rien n empeche un systeme chaotique d’etre borne.
Regarde la cigarette et la piece.
Leroux parle clairement de l abscence de modelisation des discontinuites. => modeles simplistes et donc faux
Linzden parle des problemes de modelisation => modeles simplistes donc faux
Etc…
A Murps
Merci de toutes tes precisions!
Sinon que de souvenirs de la mecaflotte…
En tout cas il fait moins dans la desinformation
Et surtout il ne melange pas tout les problemes
@ Raoul, desole j ai oublie de le preciser plus haut
Nicolas : parler de climat global ca n’a pas vraiment de sens.
Et il me semble que rien n empeche un systeme chaotique d’etre borne. Regarde la cigarette et la piece.
Etc…
Nicolas,
Ton exemple avec la cigarette est un problème lié aux conditions initiales. Le climat est un problème de conditions aux limites.
C’est important de bien réaliser la différence entre ces deux approches, sinon on parle dans le vide.